LP2824 Printing Printer Commands instead of Labels after Windows 10 Upgrade

We have an LP2824 printer that used to print like the image on the left.  Now after upgrading windows, it prints, like the the image on the right.  It's printing the raw code, instead of printing out the barcode itself. 


On this PC, we do have to Zebra printers connected.  One still works correctly and the other one does not.  We compared the settings of both printers in windows 10 control panel, and both appear to be the same. 


It's as if the printer is printing, directly as text instead of talking to the driver.  What do we need to do to get the 2nd printer to print barcodes correctly again?